Review : Plug-in solution for LAN-less offices

Motorola’s Powerline MU Gateway brings LAN connectivity to buildings via the mains

Written by Dave Bailey

Larger Image

Motorola’s Powerline Multiple-Unit (MU) Gateway is designed to offer a quick and easy way of providing buildings with LAN connectivity over the mains electricity supply. Motorola is a member of the HomePlug Powerline Alliance, and the system works by converting Ethernet signals into the HomePlug protocol before injecting it directly into a building’s electrical system.

The gateway operates in the 4-21MHz spectrum and can be used in single-phase or three-phase electrical systems, with security being taken care of by the 56bit Data Encryption Standard (DES).

Raw Powerline data rates are currently 85Mbit/s and Motorola quotes typical user data transfer rates of about 8-12Mbit/s per gateway. The maximum transmission distance between Gateway and modem is 100 metres, and one Powerline MU Gateway can serve up to 50 users simultaneously.

Firms thinking of installing a system for LAN connectivity over mains power must have a site visit from Motorola to establish the layout of the electricity supply in the building. Installation also requires the co-operation of the firm’s maintenance contractor.

The system can be used in large single properties, multiple units and across enterprise campuses. Powerline MU products are designed to be used on low-voltage wiring, which in the UK means 230V and 50Hz AC.

The system can use two methods of injecting the signal into the mains: inductively coupled injection or capacitive injection. The inductive coupler consists of non-conductive ferrite rings that can be wrapped around the electric cables in the electricity distribution cabinet, with one coupler being used per electrical phase. The signal penetrates the cable’s insulation and enters the electric lines without touching the bare wire. Motorola says this is its preferred signal injection method for multi-metered buildings.

For our test we used capacitive injection to send signals between two modem s, a desktop PC and a laptop. We connected the gateway to a switch to get internet access, although users can configure the gateway’s onboard WAN link to be front-ended by a firewall before connection to a router.

The modems would normally be connected to a switch or wireless access point to give connectivity to desktop systems. This is the method we pursued while the gateway was connected to a switch and then through our four-port BT ADSL router. We also attached our 3Com AP7250 wireless access point to one of the modems, allowing us to access the internet wirelessly.

The Gateway is fairly simple and can be managed through a web-based interface or by using a dedicated management package called Prizm, which we installed on our Windows Server 2003 system.

Data transfer rates

We checked data transfer rates by measuring the time it took to send a 160MB file between the laptop and a shared drive on the desktop system. By placing the modem attached to our laptop at increasing distances from the gateway we could build up a picture of how transfer rates fared as the modem got further away from the gateway’s signal injection point.

The desktop was connected to one of the four 10/100Mbit/s LAN ports on the gateway. An initial measurement with the modem next to the gateway’s injection point gave a transfer rate of 10.9Mbit/s, while moving the laptop to a desk a few feet away resulted in a data transfer rate dropping to 3.6Mbit/s. We then plugged the laptop into a socket some 18 feet from the unit and recorded a rate of 1.2Mbit/s. We could not ascertain whether these varied results were down to the electrically hostile Labs environment or due to a non-optimal signal injection position.

To tackle situations where the transfer rate falls off rapidly, Motorola offers modem distribution units that act as repeaters to increase signal strengths. These units can service up to four modems.

Each Powerline modem has four LEDs that indicate whether the unit is receiving AC power, whether it can detect Powerline signals on the wires, whether it has established an Ethernet link to connected devices, and finally whether it has registered with the nearest Powerline gateway.

Managing the system by browsing to the gateway’s web page was straightforward. We could set network encryption keys, whether the gateway was to use DHCP and which authentication servers to use. We could also set up SNMP traps for problem condition alerts. It was easy to see which modems were currently up and running, and to get access to systems logs.

Tags:

Product overview

  • Price: £728 for Powerline MU Gateway
  • Web site: Motorola

Ratings

  • Our rating: 3
  • Average user rating:

Verdict

Motorola's Powerline MU system makes it easy to set up LAN connections using the mains electricity supply, but a site survey by Motorola is needed before installation.

Pros : Easy set up and management, once optimal positioning of signal injection points for the gateway(s) is established.

Cons : Relatively sluggish performance compared with standard 100Mbit/s switched networks.

Phone : Motorola 01256 484168

Best prices

reader comments

related articles

image: gigabit switch

Getting started with home networking

Avoid the pitfalls when setting up your home network 05 Oct 2007

 

today's top stories

Analysis: The true cost of printing

Organisations need to get a better sense of how much they spend on printing before finding ways to reduce it 05 Sep 2008

Computing podcast 4 September 2008

Find out what Michael Dell told Computing, and listen to our take on the latest browser wars 04 Sep 2008

Looking to the future - exclusive Michael Dell interview

Dell's chief executive talks to Computing about the way the company continues to adapt to major changes in the industry 04 Sep 2008

Interview: Delivering power where it's needed at Betfair

The online gambling firm is putting its money on grid computing and virtualisation to underpin global expansion 04 Sep 2008

E-paper displays are an open book

A display revolution is on the way - but only once the user interface issues are solved 04 Sep 2008

Most commented stories

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you use a mobile phone as an alternative to cash?

Would you use a mobile phone as an alternative to cash?

When mobile phones include inbuilt payment technology - would you use one instead of cash?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

BlackBerry BoldVideo

Video Review: BlackBerry Bold

Technology editor Daniel Robinson takes a hands-on look at the latest device from Research in Motion 01 Sep 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast 4 September 2008

Find out what Michael Dell told Computing, and listen to our take on the latest browser wars 04 Sep 2008

Latest in-depth articles

A meetingAnalysis

Turning adversity into an advantage

IT chiefs under pressure to make cost cuts can turn the situation to their benefit 04 Sep 2008

CloudAnalysis

How to introduce cloud computing into your organisation

Best practice advice from Forrester Research 04 Sep 2008

Primary Navigation