Insider - Shine a light on fraud

Employees commit around 85% of all fraud - but creating an atmosphere of fear and mistrust in the workplace is not the answer.

Written by John Smart

Joyti De-Laurey and Denise Ibbertson may not be household names, but you can guarantee their former employers at Goldman Sachs and HSBC won't forget them in a hurry. Between them they were responsible for defrauding their companies out of more than £4m, not to mention dragging the reputations of those businesses through the mud.

There is a school of thought that says a certain level of fraud is, quite simply, 'the cost of doing business' - the result of outdated and ineffective internal controls, aggressive accounting practices and the growing complexity of organisations. But what these examples - alongside high-profile cases at Parmalat and Enron - illustrate all too well is how often most large frauds are committed by those working inside a company.

In fact around 85% of frauds are committed by employees, according to our own research, and 55% of these are carried out by managers. Financial damage aside, fraud diverts a great deal of senior management time and can have a damaging effect on the morale of the organisation, not to mention its reputation.

But is the right response to treat all employees as budding Nick Leesons and create a big brother atmosphere of mistrust and constant employee monitoring? The answer is no, but there are a number of steps companies can take to reduce the risk of employee fraud - without creating an atmosphere of fear and suspicion.

It's essential to make sure you have a culture of honesty and openness in your company. This is not simply about spamming employees with emails outlining the company's ethics policy. Emails of this type are rarely read and, when they are, they are quickly forgotten.

Take a step back. Most business leaders cannot pinpoint their company's culture, nor do they really know how honest their employees are, as this tale from the 1990s illustrates.

The board of directors of a car parts manufacturer wanted a photograph of its workforce on the cover of the annual report, and commissioned a photographer to take photos of a happy smiling workforce leaving the premises on a Friday afternoon. But in order to get the whole workforce into the picture, the gates of the factory had to be shut at 4.30pm as the photographer set up his equipment outside.

The workforce was rather surprised to be kept in the car park with cameras pointed at them on a Friday afternoon. But once the photos were taken and the gates opened, the directors watching the spectacle from a window overlooking the gates were horrified to see £10,000 worth of car parts discarded in the car park.

It's a salutary lesson that most directors are not aware of the culture at the coal face in their business. Measuring the awareness of fraud and employees' reaction to it within the organisation is important in understanding how serious an issue it is. Surveys have found that a significant number of employees admit to being aware of fraud in the workplace, but an equally significant number would not report this fraud to the relevant management.

The question is, where does trust end and supervision begin? A company should strike a balance between the trust it needs to place in its employees and the level of supervision necessary to make the chances of discovery a significant deterrent to the fraudster. And there are a number of good practices that could be adopted to encourage the right type of culture in an organisation.

You should set the right tone from the top of the organisation by not tolerating dishonest or unscrupulous practices. At the same time, a sound code of corporate ethics and a fraud policy should be communicated and implemented. Management must be made aware of the risk of fraud, and active discussion about how fraud prevention policies can be tightened should be encouraged.

From an employee perspective, you should actively pursue employee references, particularly for sensitive positions in treasury, procurement or financial accounting. Psychometric testing and personality profiling can screen out those employees who display dishonest or unscrupulous characteristics - such testing is already employed by a number of high-profile organisations.

And keep an eye out for the warning signs. It's much easier with hindsight, but we have been called into investigate many instances of employees carrying out fraud where some fairly obvious indicators have been ignored.

In particular, you should look out for employees whose lifestyle is very different from their known sources of income. Other warning signs include key staff who work excessive hours, refuse to delegate apparently mundane tasks, don't take any holidays or refuse to take promotion. They may also come up with regular excuses for not carrying out mundane accounting reconciliation and control procedures.

Employers ignore these warning signs at their own peril. But while it is important to handle any enquires into employee's lifestyles very sensitively, having a culture where fraud is tolerated is potentially as bad for morale as a culture that instinctively distrusts all employees.

When a fraud is suspected or detected, it is important that it is thoroughly investigated and the results of the investigation are communicated to all those affected by it. In particular, you should make a positive statement about treatment of any fraudsters. It is more important that the organisation communicates openly and trusts its employees rather than attempt to sweep all rumours about fraud under the carpet. Such rumours rarely stay under the carpet for long.

John Smart is a partner at Ernst & Young and a fraud specialist in the firm's global investigations and dispute advisory practice.

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

 

related whitepapers

today's top stories

IT's stock is soaring at the LSE

London Stock Exchange IT chief David Lester explains to Angelica Mari how the integration of Borsa Italiana is keeping his team busy, despite the worsening economy 20 Nov 2008

Keeping IT in fashion

John Bovill has been hooked on retail since his early years as a fashion market trader. His industry knowledge is now helping him build a slick IT operation, reports Charlotte Moore 20 Nov 2008

Cutting-edge IT delivers the goods

Chief technology officer Jay Bregman explains how constant innovation is part and parcel of his strategy for delivering competitive advantage at eCourier 20 Nov 2008

Computing podcast: Europol's data sharing woes; credit card protection at Cotton Traders

The pan-European fight against organised crime is undermined by lax data sharing arrangements; and Cotton Traders enhances its credit card protection 20 Nov 2008

Keeping IT on track

Catherine Doran, winner of Computing’s IT Leader of the Year award, tells Angelica Mari of her determination to drive on with technology-led transformation at Network Rail despite uncertainty over funding 19 Nov 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will attempts to rebrand IT as a "cool" choice of profession increase the number of IT graduates?

Will attempts to rebrand IT as a "cool" choice of profession increase the number of IT graduates?

Can brand building reverse a decline in IT graduate numbers?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Video

The definitive guide to converged communications

Five key trends and five best practice tips to help you improve your corporate communications 20 Nov 2008

PodcastAudio

Computing podcast: Europol's data sharing woes; credit card protection at Cotton Traders

The pan-European fight against organised crime is undermined by lax data sharing arrangements; and Cotton Traders enhances its credit card protection 20 Nov 2008

Latest in-depth articles

StarFeatures

Retaining the stars of IT

Jim Mortleman investigates the innovative techniques IT leaders are using to hang on to their star performers 20 Nov 2008

Dave BaileyComment

Clouds darken outlook for Vista's successor

Windows 7 looks like being an improvement on Vista, but economic and environmental concerns may mean few enterprises will rush to adopt it 20 Nov 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation