Children
Children who commit crimes to be put on DNA database

Scotland proposes DNA database for children

Review to be undertaken by forensic experts

Written by Andrea-Marie Vassou

Scottish children who commit sexual or violent offences could have their DNA stored on a police database under a review of the law surrounding DNA retention.

Scottish police currently must destroy the fingerprint and DNA records of all suspects who are not convicted, except where a suspect is arrested or detained and criminal proceedings were raised against them for a sexual or violent offence.

Laws were changed in January to delay the destruction of DNA records in such cases for a period of three years, or potentially longer with the agreement of a sheriff.

The review, which will examine the case for holding on to this DNA, will be carried out by Professor James Fraser, head of Strathclyde University's Centre for Forensic Science and a former president of the Forensic Science Society.

Scotland has also opted out of following English and Wales in creating a national DNA database which is believed to have kept the DNA of more than 100,000 children who have been arrested and then released for crimes such as loitering or littering.

Justifying the Scottish Government's plans, Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill said the review would focus on individuals prosecuted for violent and sexual offences, checking whether the procedures introduced in January are effective.

It would also examine why it should be lawful to retain DNA records but require fingerprint records to be destroyed.

"Our government has already made clear we do not support the blanket retention of all forensic information taken from innocent people. We are not persuaded, for example, that it would generally be right for the police to keep fingerprints and DNA samples from everyone who is detained but not convicted, or even prosecuted,” he said.

His words were enough to some appease human rights activists such as Genewatch, which lobbies against the blanket retention of DNA.

Dr Helen Wallace, a representative the organisation said she was relaxed about profiles being kept of juveniles as long as the “proposal was justified by evidence that it's likely to prevent serious crimes."

reader comments

related articles

Watchdog slams Paw Law for kids

Children digitally finger-printed without parents' consent 22 Jul 2002

 

Children’s DNA stored on Government database

Rights groups fight to remove children’s DNA details from database 23 May 2007

MPs outraged by pupil fingerprinting

Guidelines raise concerns over security, consent and access 30 Jul 2007

'Tell parents' about pupil fingerprinting

Data Protection Act states schools do not need parental consent to gather data 09 Feb 2007

DNA database 'criminalises' the innocent

Government inquiry demands removal of one million DNA records from national database 31 Jul 2008

Innocents should be removed from DNA database

Inquiry calls for purge of a million records 01 Aug 2008

UK's top computer forensics expert escapes jail

Jim Bates sentenced for making false written witness statements and perjury 10 Apr 2008

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Computing launches all-new IT jobs site

Updated Computingcareers.co.uk provides enhanced feature for jobseekers 14 Oct 2008

Q&A: BT Business head of SaaS, Chris Lindsay

BT's head of software-as-a-service explains the benefits of the on-demand delivery model and how the current economic downturn could force firms to re-evaluate how they buy software 14 Oct 2008

WiMax: Threat or opportunity?

We examine the merits of WiMax and its benefits relative to other wireless technologies in our latest video 13 Oct 2008

Learning from the credit crunch to avoid a broadband crunch

While it might be the most pressing issue de jour , the financial system isn’t the only area where government needs to... 10 Oct 2008

How careerism can warp IT procurement

Many working in IT put their career interests before those of their employer when weighing up purchasing options 10 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job


IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Are you worried about your job prospects in IT over the next 12 months?

Are you worried about your job prospects in IT over the next 12 months?

Will the economic crisis affect your job prospects?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Remote workerVideo

WiMax: Threat or opportunity?

We examine the merits of WiMax and its benefits relative to other wireless technologies in our latest video 13 Oct 2008

programming codeVideo

The definitive guide to software development

Five key trends and five best practice tips to help you improve your programming capabilities 09 Oct 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Analysis

Q&A: Jonathon Schwartz, chief executive, Business Objects

Q&A: Business Object's chief executive John Schwartz outlines how the company's acquisition by SAP will benefit end users 14 Oct 2008

Chris LindsayAnalysis

Q&A: BT Business head of SaaS, Chris Lindsay

BT's head of software-as-a-service explains the benefits of the on-demand delivery model and how the current economic downturn could force firms to re-evaluate how they buy software 14 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation