Picture of a judge hitting a gavel
Symbian's win could benefit UK software makers

High Court rewrites UK software patent rules

Symbian's successful appeal has significant implications for UK software industry, say experts

Written by Neon Kelly

The High Court has passed a ruling that for the first time allows computer programs to be patented in the UK.

The decision came about as the court upheld an appeal from Symbian following the rejection of an application the software firm made to the Intellectual Patent Office (IPO).

Symbian filed for a patent relating to the way computers use a library of functions that can be accessed by programs. The claim was discarded by the IPO last July, on the grounds that it related to software-based innovation - the IPO says patents are not available in the UK for solely computer-based programs, only for inventions that use software programs.

But yesterday Mr Justice Patten ruled that making such exclusions puts UK software companies at an unfair disadvantage compared with rival developers in Europe, where the legal landscape works differently. The European Patent Office (EPO) has already approved Symbian's application.

The decision represents a major breakthrough for the UK software industry, said Nick Wallin, patent attorney at law firm Withers & Rogers.

“All companies that invest in research and development should be free to obtain patent protection for their developments without being exposed to a series of arbitrary and outdated exclusions that undermine the value of their inventions,” said Wallin, who represented Symbian during the case.

And the High Court's decision could lead to greater harmonisation between UK and European patent offices, according to Dr John Collins, partner at Marks & Clerk.

"Throughout the judgment, there was repeated reference to the impossible division in treatment at the UK Intellectual Property Office and the European Patent Office, said Collins.

"Whilst the UK office recognises its examination process is different to that at the European level, it states that this resolves in the same outcome. This clearly is not the case, when the EPO accepts the same application that the UK office has rejected under its own treatment of software patentability."

The IPO plans to contest the ruling at the Court of Appeal, on the grounds that the judge did not follow procedures created following a benchmark case in 2006.

reader comments

related articles

EU innovation

EU delays innovation legislation

Industry says delay could damage research and development 22 Dec 2004

 

Lord Sainsbury backs EU patent directive

Science and innovation minister says directive will foster and support innovation 14 Dec 2004

BTG sues Amazon over intellectual property rights

Claims an undisclosed amount of damages over web tracking technology 16 Sep 2004

Software developers warned of legal risks

Increasingly litigious patent infringement environment can be a minefield for IT directors 18 Aug 2004

Lawyers herald software patent victory

Symbian ruling could boost UK software development 19 Mar 2008

Lawyers herald software patent victory

Symbian ruling could boost UK software development 19 Mar 2008

Brown defends database state

Systems are vital to protecting the country against fraud and terrorism, PM insists 20 Jun 2008

today's top stories

Analysis: The true cost of printing

Organisations need to get a better sense of how much they spend on printing before finding ways to reduce it 05 Sep 2008

Computing podcast 4 September 2008

Find out what Michael Dell told Computing, and listen to our take on the latest browser wars 04 Sep 2008

Looking to the future - exclusive Michael Dell interview

Dell's chief executive talks to Computing about the way the company continues to adapt to major changes in the industry 04 Sep 2008

Interview: Delivering power where it's needed at Betfair

The online gambling firm is putting its money on grid computing and virtualisation to underpin global expansion 04 Sep 2008

E-paper displays are an open book

A display revolution is on the way - but only once the user interface issues are solved 04 Sep 2008

Most commented stories

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you use a mobile phone as an alternative to cash?

Would you use a mobile phone as an alternative to cash?

When mobile phones include inbuilt payment technology - would you use one instead of cash?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

BlackBerry BoldVideo

Video Review: BlackBerry Bold

Technology editor Daniel Robinson takes a hands-on look at the latest device from Research in Motion 01 Sep 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast 4 September 2008

Find out what Michael Dell told Computing, and listen to our take on the latest browser wars 04 Sep 2008

Latest in-depth articles

A meetingAnalysis

Turning adversity into an advantage

IT chiefs under pressure to make cost cuts can turn the situation to their benefit 04 Sep 2008

CloudAnalysis

How to introduce cloud computing into your organisation

Best practice advice from Forrester Research 04 Sep 2008

Primary Navigation