Corporate governance: Stand to reason

Sir Derek Higgs’s no-nonsense approach to corporate governance was just what was needed post-Enron

Written by Robert Bruce

Cultural change works at different speeds. Sometimes it can take generations to come through; at other times, it almost happens overnight. Change comes fastest when there is a consensus, if unexpressed, that success is desired and needed. This probably is the real legacy of the great corporate governance revolution that has changed the landscape of British business over the past 15 years or so. From the Cadbury report in 1992, through the Smith and Higgs reviews in 2003, changes that seemed earth-shattering at the time and that raised a considerable head of opposition are now seen as comfortable parts of the corporate landscape. The man behind that last review, Sir Derek Higgs, who passed away in April, made a contribution worth a review in itself.

Sir Derek was one of those people who did decent things in a way that commanded respect. He was a man of extraordinary abilities who, because he appeared so ordinary in his approach, managed to reach people by moving almost under their radar, and achieve far more than many realised at the time. This was why he was the right man to produce a review of the role and effectiveness of non-executive directors in the sometimes fevered post-Enron environment.

By putting forward a framework reliant on the reasonableness of people, he created something which would withstand any furious opposition or efforts to create greater confusion – this was in the early days of Sarbanes-Oxley, after all. The UK could have easily slipped down the path towards astonishing corporate bureaucracy, but the Higgs route took us to a world where processes and safeguards made sense. And it took us down a route that reinforced the idea that principles are better than rules.

Take the recent shouting match over the role of chairman and chief executive at Marks & Spencer. What is happening goes against the ideas championed by the Higgs report. But because that report also strengthened the idea of ‘comply or explain’ it has been possible for both sides to achieve what they wanted. M &S has a combined chairman and chief executive and the investment community has put its views across very clearly. The results will unravel over the next year. But the company will find the going difficult. It has backed itself into a position which, though satisfying internal politics, can only end in tears or, at best, in results which are very uncomfortable. Every slightest slip will be magnified. The investment community has the upper hand, but M&S is weakened.

Higgs’s point was that businesses need differentiation between the leadership of the board and the running of the business. Everyone knows this to be right and proper. It was the strength of the Higgs review simply to turn common sense into guiding principle.

But there was more to Higgs’s review than simply keeping those principles in place. It also created an atmosphere in which businesses could, well, get on with their business. Higgs was a man who wanted nonsense gone. He was one of those people with a knack for spotting essential truths amid much confusion. He had a way of putting his finger on the issue that teased out common sense. This was why he occasionally, in the process of producing his report, had problems with politicians. He would go for sense, while politicians, for their own peculiarly convoluted reasons, would go for nonsense. For Higgs this was ridiculous. But for the politicians, who were playing their own games, it wasn’t. Ultimately, when it finally appeared after much consultation and behind-the-scenes manoeuvring, the Higgs report was clarity personified. And corporate reporting has since followed that lead.

Sir Derek’s review made this succinct in his opening letter, presenting his report to the Chancellor of the Exchequer. The existing combined code and its principle of comply or explain, he said, “offers flexibility and intelligent discretion and allows for the valid exception to the sound rule. The brittleness and rigidity of legislation cannot dictate the behaviour, or foster the trust I believe is fundamental to the effective unitary board and to superior corporate performance.”

Higgs had a huge advantage over his opponents in the corporate world because he knew where the real drivers of change lay. “This is not about science,” he said. “It is about people.” And that is why change followed. In the introduction to his report, it says: “Corporate governance provides an architecture of accountability – the structures and processes to ensure companies are managed in the interests of their owners.” And then he immediately follows that with: “But architecture in itself does not deliver good outcomes. The review, therefore, also focuses on the conditions and behaviours necessary for non-executive director to be fully effective.”

This is why Higgs’s work has had such a lasting effect. He dealt with human beings, not theories. As he said in answer to a question at the press conference that launched the review: “We are dealing with grown-up intelligent people who know what bad practice is.” And, by and large, good practice has driven out bad many times since.

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

 

Shareholders rocked by water chief's past

Northumbrian Water's failure to disclose in its annual report that its chairman had stepped down as chairman of the audit and risk committees at collapsed bank Northern Rock could raise difficult questions 31 Jul 2008

Firms vent fury over disciplinary costs

The CBI is expected to be drawn into the issue over concerns about the likely impact the changes will have on company directors 14 Feb 2008

Sir Derek Higgs dies suddenly

Author of corporate governance reforms dies in hospital after being taken ill 29 Apr 2008

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Solid as a rock - business continuity in a global manufacturer

From power supply problems in Nigeria to email availability in Stockport, PZ Cussons is prepared for anything 02 Dec 2008

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

IT staff desperate to keep their jobs

Most would work longer hours for less pay 02 Dec 2008

VMware View 3 enhances virtual desktops

Virtual clients now take up less storage space and can be 'checked out' to a laptop 02 Dec 2008

Technology and privacy

Watch part one of a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 01 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Is India becoming a risky destination?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Padlocked CDVideo

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - Standard Life's offshoring plans; and the prospects for government IT

The insurance giant outlines its new outsourcing strategy; and we ask if the government's economic bailout will affect its IT plans 28 Nov 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Parcel being packedFeatures

Case study: eSpares and business continuity

Online electricals business has managed to decrease its downtime 02 Dec 2008

Royal Blackburn HospitalFeatures

NHS trust recovers from server overdose

Virtualisation technology breathed new life into East Lancashire's cost-intensive system 02 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation