IT fails the A-level test, again

The claims that A-levels are getting easier hide the problem of falling numbers in technical subjects

Written by James Murray

Thank God August is over. Stories about sharks off Cornwall and scientific conclusions from the Institute of Studies in the Blindingly Obvious and Pointless will now no longer masquerade as news items.

The start of September should also silence the annual press bleatings that improving A-level results are proof that the exams are getting easier.

There are two things wrong with this week-long festival of academic accusations. First, as Peter Wilby explained in The Guardian, the argument that standards are slipping is spurious because papers are comparing results that have come from curricula, exams, and a social context that have necessarily changed over time, making comparisons worthless.

Wilby rightly observes, “The world is changing at unprecedented speed, so why do we want schools to stand still, teaching roughly the same things as 10, 20 or 30 years ago so that we can reliably compare ‘standards’?”

Second, the row over results always serves to distract from the more important debate over what subjects the results are in.

This year was yet another bad one for IT A-levels, with the number of students taking computing falling 10 per cent to 5,610 and entrants for ICT falling six per cent to 13,360.

Apologists may claim that neither of these qualifications are essential for taking IT-related subjects at university or pursuing a technology career, and that the number of students sitting maths A-levels ­ often a requirement for university IT courses ­ has climbed 14 per cent since 2004.

However, these figures remain a failure for a government that has spent millions attempting to promote science and technology as attractive career options. With the exception of a few encouraging case studies, such as the Computer Club for Girls, there is little evidence that the money is working.

The idea that you can catch up at university or in the workplace through better courses and training has some merit, but it is misleading to suggest it can solve the IT skills crisis alone. Attitudes are shaped at an early age and the prevailing attitude towards IT among many school children is that it is a singularly unattractive career option.

Rather than a ridiculous week arguing about whether or not exams are getting easier, we need a serious debate on how we can encourage students to acquire the technical and scientific skills the UK’s economy desperately needs.

Otherwise, businesses will respond to our worsening IT skills shortage by shipping more IT work offshore, taking with it much of the UK’s ability to compete in the knowledge economy.

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

people learning

IT professionals unaware of skills initiatives

Survey finds majority of IT pros are unaware of skills development support from bodies such as SFIA 22 Aug 2007

 

UK IT staff have greater access to training than European counterparts

But overall levels of training continue to decline as concerns over skills shortages mount 14 Aug 2007

IT graduates still lack practical experience

But skills shortage may be overhyped, says IBM 10 Aug 2007

Training unlocks WLAN benefits

Firms missing the benefits of wireless LAN deployments due to complexity and maintenance burdens 31 Jul 2007

related whitepapers

today's top stories

CIOs must embrace collaboration tools

Author Don Tapscott gives Angelica Mari his reasons for promoting social networking tools and says transparency is the key to security 04 Dec 2008

On a quest to build a connected society

BT Design’s JP Rangaswami talks to Gareth Morgan about his pivotal role in the telecoms giant’s efforts to deliver universal broadband and his plans to tap into the creativity of the open source community 04 Dec 2008

IT leaders must stand by India

A sense of perspective is the most important response from IT leaders to the attacks in Mumbai 04 Dec 2008

Case study: Clifford Chance

Law firm implements Sun platform and reduces datacentres to gain efficiency and cost synergies 03 Dec 2008

Should CRM be more sociable?

As vendors rush to add more social networking bells and whistles to their CRM products, some experts warn that users must tread carefully when venturing into online communities 03 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Is India becoming a risky destination?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Padlocked CDVideo

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - Standard Life's offshoring plans; and the prospects for government IT

The insurance giant outlines its new outsourcing strategy; and we ask if the government's economic bailout will affect its IT plans 28 Nov 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Doctors looking at a computerAnalysis

Watchdog wants IT to cure privacy woes

Information Commissioner Richard Thomas is urging organisations to put privacy protection at the top of their procurement and development criteria 04 Dec 2008

Colin McDonaldComment

Web 2.0 has potential to transform staff training

Employees can sharpen their IT skills through using the latest interactive training tools, writes Colin McDonald 04 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation