Review: iPhone 3G boosts web experience

Apple's 3G iPhone has faster web access, but lags behind other mobiles in corporate features

Written by Daniel Robinson

Larger Image

The iPhone 3G is an updated version of Apple's touch-screen smartphone, adding support for faster 3G network connections and also GPS capability for location-based services such as navigation. However, despite the addition of some enterprise-friendly features, the iPhone is still more of a consumer device than a business tool.

Available in the UK since July on O2's network, the iPhone 3G is a slick, user-friendly device that offers support for Microsoft Exchange email systems and an impressive web browser. This makes the device attractive for accessing web-based applications, but the lack of a keyboard will be a handicap for many users, and its device management capabilities are still rudimentary compared with other platforms.

The new iPhone is almost identical in appearance to the first version, with a 3.5in display that almost fills the front panel. There are few other controls – a single button beneath the screen returns the user to the "home" screen when pressed, an on/off switch is on the top edge of the case, and the left edge has a ringer off toggle and volume up/down button.

At 133g, the iPhone is heaver than a standard phone, but still lighter than many smartphones. It is also roughly the same size as many rival devices, such as the BlackBerry Curve. Like the original iPhone, this new model has 802.11b/g Wi-Fi and Bluetooth in addition to its GSM and 3G cellular radios.

Unlike most other touch-screen devices, the iPhone's user interface is entirely finger driven. No stylus is supplied, as these do not work - the screen does not respond to pressure. A bonus of this is that you are less likely to accidentally dial a number with the iPhone in a bag or your pocket. The device's 320x480 display is also one of the best we have seen on any mobile device.

The home screen presents a set of application icons that the user simply touches to activate, with key functions such as phone, email and Safari (web browser) in a row at the bottom of the display. Inside an application, the controls are likewise activated by touch. When data input is required, an on-screen keyboard appears, and some functions are controlled by gestures. Inside the browser, for example, putting two fingers on the screen and pulling them apart zooms in, while an on-screen slider control is used to unlock the device.

We found the on-screen keyboard unsatisfactory compared with a physical keyboard, especially those on many BlackBerry models. Whenever your finger goes anywhere near the screen, it registers as a keypress, often causing the wrong character to be entered. In our experience, this makes the iPhone unsuitable for heavy-duty messaging, although the phone dialling keypad with fewer keys works just fine.

The iPhone's new 3G support provides HSDPA download speeds up to 3.6Mbit/s, and we found this noticeably improved loading of web pages in the Safari browser compared with the original iPhone, although browsing over a Wi-Fi connection is still faster.

For enterprise customers, the iPhone 3G now supports Microsoft's Exchange, and is capable of receiving email, contacts and calendar updates pushed over the cellular connection. Administrators can also gain limited control of an iPhone using policies applied via Exchange, such as enforcing passwords or remotely wiping a device. However, the iPhone does not implement all Exchange features.

To provision a handset, the iPhone 3G supports Configuration Profiles, XML files that contain settings for device security policies, VPN configuration, Exchange settings and certificates. Apple provides a web-based configuration console that enables administrators to create configuration files and email them direct to users from the console itself, or post them to a web site for downloading.

The other major new feature of the iPhone 3G is GPS. This provides the user's location for applications such as the built-in Google Maps, which can give directions to local amenities and user-specified destinations. The iPhone supports Assisted GPS (A-GPS), which makes use of information from the cellular network as well as satellites to determine location.

We found that the iPhone was unable to get a fix on our location in central London, due to the number of tall buildings that interfere with the satellite signals. Outside the capital, however, the iPhone had no difficulty pinpointing the location within minutes.

Another new feature aimed at enterprise buyers is VPN support. This includes L2TP, PPTP and Cisco IPSec protocols, with authentication via RSA SecurID or CryptoCard tokens. L2TP and PPTP additionally support MS-CHAPv2 authentication.

From a business perspective, the iPhone 3G thus has potential for some vertical applications, if developers can match the level of ease of use demonstrated in the built-in software. Our review unit shipped with 16GB of Flash storage (an 8GB unit is also available), which should provide ample space for applications and data.

This must be measured against the fact that the iPhone doubles as an iPod media player and has a link from the home screen direct to the iTunes music store, features that are unlikely to endear the device to corporate buyers.

There is also no easy way for a customer to replace the battery. Unlike most other mobile handsets, this means that users cannot carry a spare on a business trip in case the main battery runs out. It also means that the iPhone must be returned to Apple to replace a defective battery.

Apple would not specify the size of the battery inside the new iPhone, but quotes the handset as lasting for five hours of talk time, or up to 300 hours on standby. Apple also claims the device can deliver up to five hours internet use on a 3G connection, or six hours on Wi-Fi.

Tags:

Product overview

  • Price: £135.32 for 16GB model, £84.26 for 8GB model; free on many O2 tariffs
  • Web site: Apple

Ratings

  • Our rating: 3
  • Average user rating:

Verdict

Apple's iPhone 3G is a good choice for those needing a phone with a decent browser for web access, but its lack of a keyboard and minimal management controls mean it is no replacement for a BlackBerry as a corporate messaging device. Its touch-screen and generous Flash storage might make it attractive as a platform for vertical applications.

PROS: Good screen and user interface; excellent browser; built-in GPS

CONS: No keyboard; non-removable battery

Best prices

reader comments

related articles

iphone

O2 unveils iPhone business package

Business users can get hands on the latest 3G iPhone at special corporate rates from 11 July 04 Jul 2008

 

iAnywhere puts email on 3G iPhone

Sybase tool provides support for Exchange and Domino on the iPhone 23 Jul 2008

Apple aims 3G iPhone at firms

New iPhone comes with ActiveSync support for Exchange 10 Jun 2008

Check Point to secure iPhones

Security firm Check Point could make it easier for businesses to roll out iPhones 04 Jun 2008

No penalty to upgrade to iPhone 3G

Just sign on the dotted line for another 18 months 10 Jun 2008

Palm Treo Pro targets business professionals

New handset takes on Nokia E71 and BlackBerry Bold 20 Aug 2008

Nokia 'iPhone killer' specs leaked

N96 'multimedia computer' expected to cost €550 13 Feb 2008

today's top stories

CIOs must embrace collaboration tools

Author Don Tapscott gives Angelica Mari his reasons for promoting social networking tools and says transparency is the key to security 04 Dec 2008

On a quest to build a connected society

BT Design’s JP Rangaswami talks to Gareth Morgan about his pivotal role in the telecoms giant’s efforts to deliver universal broadband and his plans to tap into the creativity of the open source community 04 Dec 2008

IT leaders must stand by India

A sense of perspective is the most important response from IT leaders to the attacks in Mumbai 04 Dec 2008

Case study: Clifford Chance

Law firm implements Sun platform and reduces datacentres to gain efficiency and cost synergies 03 Dec 2008

Should CRM be more sociable?

As vendors rush to add more social networking bells and whistles to their CRM products, some experts warn that users must tread carefully when venturing into online communities 03 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Is India becoming a risky destination?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Padlocked CDVideo

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - Standard Life's offshoring plans; and the prospects for government IT

The insurance giant outlines its new outsourcing strategy; and we ask if the government's economic bailout will affect its IT plans 28 Nov 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Doctors looking at a computerAnalysis

Watchdog wants IT to cure privacy woes

Information Commissioner Richard Thomas is urging organisations to put privacy protection at the top of their procurement and development criteria 04 Dec 2008

Colin McDonaldComment

Web 2.0 has potential to transform staff training

Employees can sharpen their IT skills through using the latest interactive training tools, writes Colin McDonald 04 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation