Google
A US judge has upheld the objectivity of Google's search results

Judge dismisses Google ranking lawsuit

KinderStart action ruled 'factually baseless'

Written by Ian Williams

A US district court judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed against Google by KinderStart, a search engine aimed at kids and parents, as "factually baseless". 

The suit accused Google of violating free speech, unfair competition, defamation, libel and skewing search results in favour of companies that compensate Google financially.

Judge Jeremy Fogel, of San José, California, also granted a motion by Google to sanction KinderStart and one of its lawyers.

Google can now seek reasonable compensation for attorney fees after the judge ruled that KinderStart lawyer Gregory Yu filed claims that were factually baseless, and did not perform an adequate investigation before filing the lawsuit.

Judge Fogel wrote in his ruling: "Yu's purported evidence is either double hearsay or hearsay speculation as to the 'mysterious' causes of improvement in a website's position in Google's search results.

"Yu provides no evidence that would support KinderStart's broad attacks on the objectivity of Google's search results."

KinderStart's suit also alleged that Google is in the habit of removing websites from search results for "political and religious reasons", despite the fact that KinderStart did not appear to suffer any such discrimination by Google.

"While Yu has brought a novel challenge to a major corporation, it is apparent that to some extent he has overreached in doing so," Judge Fogel wrote.

"Yu had a professional responsibility to refrain from filing such allegations if he did not have appropriate supporting evidence."

Google's litigation counsel Hilary Ware said: "We always felt these claims were unjustified because courts have consistently rejected complaints over search engine rankings, so we are pleased that Judge Fogel promptly dismissed this case."

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

Google

Google tweaks search privacy protection

Information will become anonymous 18 to 24 months after a search is carried out 15 Mar 2007

 

Yahoo rubbishes Google usability

Google's services suffer under the yoke of engineers 28 Feb 2007

Viacom takes YouTube war to the courts

TV empire seeking more than $1bn over alleged copyright violations 14 Mar 2007

Wikipedia in court over defamation claims

Site prepares to defend itself 06 May 2008

Spammer loses free speech argument

Jeremy Jaynes has appeal turned down 03 Mar 2008

Rambus sues Nvidia over memory patents

Lawsuit alleges 17 violations 11 Jul 2008

related whitepapers

today's top stories

WiMax: Threat or opportunity?

We examine the merits of WiMax and its benefits relative to other wireless technologies in our latest video 13 Oct 2008

Learning from the credit crunch to avoid a broadband crunch

While it might be the most pressing issue de jour , the financial system isn’t the only area where government needs to... 10 Oct 2008

How careerism can warp IT procurement

Many working in IT put their career interests before those of their employer when weighing up purchasing options 10 Oct 2008

The definitive guide to software development

Five key trends and five best practice tips to help you improve your programming capabilities 09 Oct 2008

Computing podcast - IT implications of the banking crisis, and the FSA clamps down on IT security

We discuss the effect of shotgun mergers and acquisitions on financial services IT staff, and examine the industry regulator's plan to fine directors for information security breaches 09 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job


IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you apply for a job that was advertised on Facebook or a similar social networking site?

Would you apply for a job that was advertised on Facebook or a similar social networking site?

The government is using Facebook to recruit IT staff - would you apply to such an ad?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Remote workerVideo

WiMax: Threat or opportunity?

We examine the merits of WiMax and its benefits relative to other wireless technologies in our latest video 13 Oct 2008

programming codeVideo

The definitive guide to software development

Five key trends and five best practice tips to help you improve your programming capabilities 09 Oct 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Financial Services Authority buildingAnalysis

FSA threatens executives with fines

Senior management to be held accountable for security lapses at banks 09 Oct 2008

Comment

Broadband must be a spending priority

For the economic health of the nation, the government would do better to bankroll an optical fibre rollout rather than prop up profligate banks 09 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation